Cease saying saying pro-lifers are identical to ISIS – it is Islamophobic

I believe most girls can perceive that the concept of the state having final management over our our bodies – even right down to the contents of our uteruses – is terrifying (Picture: EPA)

Predictably, social media has been stuffed for the final week or so with outrage at the potential overthrowing of Roe v Wade by the US Supreme Court

Regardless of your private views on abortion, I believe most girls can perceive that the concept of the state having final management over our our bodies – even right down to the contents of our uteruses – is terrifying. 

But amongst the feminist takes and the ladies sharing their very own experiences with abortion, the criticism aimed toward the truth that a number of white males with socially conservative views can change the lives of thousands and thousands, and people terrified of the slippery slope this alerts for minority rights throughout the western world, I’ve seen one thing that has made me uncomfortable and exasperated – however not wholly shocked. 

I’ve seen numerous posts linking the potential overturning of Roe v Wade to Muslims or Muslimness generally, regardless of the problem having nothing to do with Islam and all the things to do with the rise of right-wing conservatism and the legacy of Trump. 

I’ve seen individuals on-line likening the state of affairs of American ladies to these residing below the Taliban, and it isn’t the witty scorching take individuals assume it’s – it’s deeply Islamophobic

Even Trevor Noah, a comic famend for speaking about racism, made a distasteful joke suggesting that America fought for 20 years in Afghanistan solely to deliver the identical legal guidelines right here – implying that the explanation for the overturning of Roe v Wade is as a result of lawmakers have been ‘jealous’ of Sharia Law, and that girls would have ‘the same abortion rights as women in Afghanistan under the Taliban’.

Comparing American pro-life campaigners to ISIS or suggesting that Americans will now be residing below ‘Sharia Law’ is downright offensive and flawed. You can assist reproductive rights with out being anti-Muslim. You can oppose pro-lifers with out invoking a non-existent Muslim enemy.

Joke or not, this neocolonial assertion that Afghanistan is backwards and that the pro-life marketing campaign is an imported phenomenon, implanted within the minds of white Americans by conniving bearded Muslims, is testomony to the prevalence of Islamophobia all through the western world.

I’m over seeing my spiritual identification warped into some form of common enemy that’s synonymous with all evil

I’m tempted to speak right here about how the Islamic rulings on abortion are much more nuanced and sophisticated than the totalitarian method the Supreme Court appears to be steering in the direction of – however the level is, I shouldn’t must. I don’t have to justify the Muslim response or desperately try and painting Islam as liberal on this subject as a result of, fairly frankly, it isn’t related right here. 

I’m bored with having to elucidate and defend. I’m over seeing my spiritual identification warped into some form of common enemy that’s synonymous with all evil. We expertise this with each terrorist assault across the globe – and now to see the identical notions so casually spouted on social media, retweeted 1000’s of occasions, is scary, undermining and draining.

Islamophobia is so deeply-rooted that it worms its method even into debates that don’t have anything to do with Islam and controversies that aren’t enacted by Muslims. Why is it that some are so unable to see fundamentalism as something however a Muslim subject? 

It presupposes that extremism is completely international to the western world, however this simply isn’t true – no matter the place you lie on the abortion subject, it’s clear that this debate lies on the very core of the American context. It shouldn’t be some imported, international, Muslim agenda. 

Islamophobia is so rife that even when American historical past tells us in any other case, some are nonetheless unable to envisage a perceived extremist as wanting like their pleasant, God-loving neighbour. Instead, to grasp and oppose state erosion of girls’s rights, they invoke a picture of an indignant bearded brown man, as if white males in fits with legislation levels can’t be accountable for the stripping of bodily autonomy of half of the American nation. 

This fuels the already rampant anti-Muslim sentiment and reinforces the concept in individuals’s minds that we’re at all times the final word enemy – when one thing is dangerous, when a legislation is oppressive: it’s mimicking Muslims. 

These false comparisons additionally create a feminist hierarchy through which Muslim ladies are perpetually and intentionally on the backside. A construction through which Muslim ladies must be relegated to ensure that non-Muslim, western ladies to thrive on the prime. 

By likening the state of affairs of American ladies to ladies residing below the Taliban or ISIS, what’s the unstated conclusion aside from that it’s OK for some ladies to be oppressed by the state however not others? That we anticipate lined, meek, Muslim ladies to face this sort of subjugation, however not enlightened westerners?

This sends a message that girls like me are used to listening to time and time once more. That feminism merely isn’t for us, or inclusive for us – that we’re nothing however the low bar upon which all different ladies’s rights are constructed.

The downside is, Muslim ladies don’t simply reside in faraway Middle-Eastern international locations – they’re American too, and this erases the 1000’s of Muslim ladies in America who will even must reside below any potential erosion of reproductive rights. Given that some concern any overhaul of Roe v Wade might even name into query the legality of medically-necessary abortions, that is notably scary. 

The value of giving start within the USA can vary from 1000’s to thousands and thousands of {dollars} and Muslim Americans are disproportionately impacted by poverty. 

Couple this with the horrifying actuality that girls of color usually tend to die in childbirth or face undiagnosed pregnancy-related problems and we see that, no matter particular person spiritual views on abortion, American Muslim ladies are set to lose simply as a lot – or extra – below any reversal of Roe v Wade. 

Muslim ladies deserve greater than to be the butt of a joke or the punchline in a viral tweet. 

Do you may have a narrative you’d wish to share? Get in contact by emailing

Share your views within the feedback beneath.

MORE : US Republican lawmakers block invoice to maintain abortion authorized nationwide earlier than Roe v Wade is overturned

MORE : ‘I’m so disgusted’: Cher and Jameela Jamil lead outrage as celebrities react to Roe v Wade Supreme Court ‘leak’

MORE : Don’t be shocked that there’s Islamophobia in politics – British Muslims actually aren’t

Source hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.